Disputed
How a protein that ages cells might be reversed to restore youthful growth

This lab study suggests one type of cellular aging caused by loss of a specific protein might be reversible—a promising idea, but far too early to be relevant to human …

22 /100
Preprint without peer review or citations. Sample size not reported. In vitro only; no in vivo validation. Aging connection is …
Disputed
Computer Model Suggests Combining Four Drugs May Slow Aging Better Than Using Them Alone

This is an interesting theoretical framework showing that aging might require different drug combinations than treating diabetes alone, but it's a computer prediction only—not evidence from actual patients. We'll need …

21 /100
Major: Preprint with zero peer review or citations. Model predictions entirely computational with no human validation. Aging layer not validated …
Disputed
Better Way to Measure Cellular Aging Markers in the Lab

This is a clever technical improvement to the standard senescence test that could make aging research more reliable—but it's still waiting for peer review and independent confirmation before labs should …

24 /100
Preprint with zero peer review or citations; sample sizes for validation not disclosed in abstract; no mention of independent lab …
Disputed
A genetic tweak that quiets inflammation in aging cells

This is early-stage laboratory work showing a genetic mutation can reduce inflammation from aging cells in a dish. It's conceptually promising but far too preliminary to predict any human benefit—much …

24 /100
Preprint (not peer-reviewed). No citation history. Sample sizes unreported. Single cell type (human primary fibroblasts). No animal studies. No disclosed …
Disputed
Making Epigenetic Age Clocks Work with DNA Sequencing Data

This preprint describes a useful technical solution for adapting aging clocks to work with modern DNA sequencing, but it's too early to rely on these findings. Wait for peer review …

24 /100
Major limitations: (1) Preprint status—not peer-reviewed; (2) Sample size not clearly reported in abstract; (3) No mention of data availability, …
Disputed
Eye fluid reveals mitochondrial damage in vision loss; alpha-ketoglutarate supplement shows promise

This early-stage, unreviewed study shows an innovative way to measure mitochondrial health in living human eyes and provides preliminary evidence that alpha-ketoglutarate supplementation can reach the eye and shift its …

23 /100
Preprint (not peer-reviewed). Very small sample size in Phase 0 cohort (N appears to be <10 for intervention arm; exact …
Disputed
NAD Precursors: What Science Says About NR vs NMN Supplements

NAD+ is genuinely important for cellular health, but the claim that NR supplements are superior to NMN or provide major exercise benefits in healthy people goes beyond current evidence. Rely …

23 /100
Community discussion — not peer-reviewed research. No peer-reviewed citations provided—only podcast timestamps. Makes definitive claims (e.g., 'NR is way more …
Disputed
Mike Lustgarten's Self-Experiment: NAD+ and Homocysteine Supplementation

This is a well-documented personal experiment showing one person's biomarker changes from supplementation, characterized by admirable honesty about disappointing results—but it provides no evidence that this supplement protocol actually slows …

24 /100
YouTube video — not peer-reviewed research. **No citations for core claims**: Homocysteine's neurotoxic mechanisms, SAM's role in homocysteine metabolism, and …
Disputed
Genetics May Account for 50% of Lifespan, New Study Suggests

While the genetic contribution to lifespan is a legitimate research question, this post cites an unverifiable study without sufficient detail to evaluate its claims. Readers should be cautious about the …

16 /100
Community discussion — not peer-reviewed research. Critical red flags include: (1) No DOI, journal, or publication details for the cited …
Disputed
How SARS-CoV-2 Shuts Down Host Cells' Protein-Making Machinery

This study reveals a clever trick SARS-CoV-2 uses to quiet host cells while amplifying its own protein production, targeting a pathway implicated in aging. However, it's a preliminary report in …

22 /100
Preprint with no peer review (bioRxiv). No sample size reported in abstract. Cell culture only—no animal or clinical data. No …
Disputed
How Your Brain Uses Predictions to Shape What You See

This is a theoretical neuroscience paper with no direct bearing on aging or longevity. While the computational model is interesting for understanding how brains use predictions, the lack of peer …

24 /100
Not peer-reviewed (preprint only). No original data collected—entirely reanalysis of published studies. Zero citations, suggesting very recent/unknown work. No declared …