Background: The lifespan of insecticide-treated nets (ITNs) varies widely across settings, reflecting both intrinsic product characteristics and external factors related to use, care, and environment. While the resistance to damage (RD) score captures intrinsic product durability, there is no standardized metric to quantify contextual risks. This study presents a proof of concept for the Risk Index (RI), a composite measure of site-level risk factors for ITN physical durability and survival. Methods: We conducted a secondary analysis of durability monitoring data from 44 sites across 15 countries in sub-Saharan Africa, covering 14 ITN products. The RI was calculated as a weighted composite of 12 indicators spanning net handling, net care attitudes, and use environment. Associations between RI and median ITN survival were assessed using weighted linear regression and multivariable mixed-effects models adjusting for RD score, with country included as a random effect. Results: RI scores ranged from 25.1 to 83.7 across study sites. In bivariable analysis, a 10-point decrease in RI was associated with a 4.0-month increase in median ITN survival (95% CI: 1.7-6.3; p=0.001). In multivariable analysis adjusting for RD, this association remained significant but attenuated to 2.2 months (95% CI: 0.1-4.2; p=0.037). Independently, a 10-point increase in RD score was associated with a 3.5-month increase in survival (95% CI: 1.3-5.7; p=0.001). No interaction was observed between RI and RD. Predicted survival differed by approximately one year between the lowest- and highest-risk settings. Conclusion: The RI provides a standardized measure of contextual risk factors affecting ITN lifespan, independent of ITN product type. When used alongside a product's RD score, the RI enables improved interpretation of expected site-level variation in net performance. This combined framework offers a practical basis for incorporating behavioural and environmental risk into vector control planning and for tailoring ITN strategies to local conditions.
Predicting the median lifespan of ITNs using an area-measure of risk of physical durability: proof of concept of the Risk Index
TL;DR
Background: The lifespan of insecticide-treated nets (ITNs) varies widely across settings, reflecting both intrinsic product characteristics and external factors related to use, care, and environment. While the resistance to damage (RD) score captures intrinsic product durability, there is no standardized metric to quantify contextual risks. This study presents a proof of concept for the Risk Index (RI), a composite measure of site-level risk factors for ITN physical durability and survival. Met
Credibility Assessment
Preliminary — 34/100
Study Design
Rigor of the research methodology
5/20
Sample Size
Whether the study was sufficiently powered
7/20
Peer Review
Review status and journal reputation
4/20
Replication
Has this finding been independently reproduced?
6/20
Transparency
Funding disclosure and data availability
12/20
Overall
Sum of all five dimensions
34/100
0 Comments
Log in to join the discussion.